Search form

MOVIE REVIEW: The Roommate

Minka Kelly and Leighton Meester not very thrilling

(L-R) Minka Kelly and Leighton Meester in "The Roommate."

(L-R) Minka Kelly and Leighton Meester in "The Roommate."

  • (L-R) Minka Kelly and Leighton Meester in "The Roommate."
View Full Gallery »

Minka Kelly, one of the main characters in The Roommate, made the guy forget about Summer in 500 Days of Summer and last year was named the sexiest woman alive by Esquire magazine (and she’s dated Derek Jeter).In this film, she goes to a college called ULA, which is supposed to be UCLA. Hearing and seeing that written is as distracting as hearing someone yell out a 555 phone number.Kelly has a new roommate in the dorm who turns out to be an obsessive psycho.

This is Single White Female for the Gossip Girl crowd (and it stars Leighton Meester from that show, who was also in another bad movie recently,Country Strong).

The leading man does a fine job looking like James Dean, James Franco, or any number of good looking James’ in Hollywood.It’s just a shame the script doesn’t give the actors enough, especially when they got the talented Francis Fisher (here’s an Oscar fun fact: Fisher was in two movies that wonBest Picture Oscars – Titanic and Unforgiven).One of her co-stars in Titanic, Billy Zane (The Phantom) is miscast as a college professor/fashionista. When he’s at the chalk board talking about designers, it reminded me of Denise Richards in that James Bond movie where she tries talking about nuclear physics.

I found it odd this film was rated PG-13 when it should’ve been PG. And if they’re going for the younger crowds without an R rating, why even show a shower scene where you have a close-up of the girls shoulder, and then her belly button?Another scene is cut between two characters making love and a phone sex conversation. Both of those scenes merely show close-ups of mouths.

People go to see these types of thrillers for boobs and blood -- or at the very least, for thrills. This had none of those things.

That being said, it’s really not as poorly written as it could’ve been. In the first half, when all the characters are introduced, it wasn’t so bad.Things go downhill in the second half of the film.

When one character calls another collect, it was like 1979 called. Who has to call anyone collect these days? And why does this character constantly forget her cell phone?

Here’s one last Oscar fun fact. Director Christian E. Christiansen was nominated for an Oscar in 2007 (for his short film At Night).

In closing, if you’re going to do a movie that everyone is going to compare to Single White Female, don’t do one of the exact same scenes; and if your movie is going to be called a psychological thriller, don’t leave out the “thriller” part of that.

It gets a D-.